Owners' decisions

Why year one is not year three

Updated 6-minute read

A timber dining table with potted succulents on a round tray

An earning appraisal bases its projection on established listings near you. They have reviews, a settled place in search results and guests who come back. A new listing starts with none of that. The market already pays the projected rate. The question is how long yours takes to earn it.

In our experience, the answer is about a year of guests. So we tell owners year one is not year three, and we say it before you sign, not after your first statement.

What a new listing doesn’t have yet

Three things, and each one comes only from guests.

  • Reviews. On Airbnb, guests are asked for a review on the day they check out, and have 14 days to write it. A listing’s star rating appears once it has at least three reviews. Until then, a guest booking for the Darwin Festival is weighing your place against listings with years of reviews behind them.
  • Ranking history. Airbnb says listings “with better ratings and reviews tend to rank higher in search”. Its search also weighs how popular a listing is, its customer service and its cancellations. A new listing has no record on any of these, so at first it competes on what it can show: its photos, its price and its open dates.
  • Repeat guests. Established listings have guests who come back: for work, to see family, for the same week every dry season. Nobody can come back before a first stay, so year one is when a listing meets the guests who might return.

Launch pricing: fill the calendar first

A new listing can’t charge an established listing’s rate and expect the same bookings. Airbnb also says listings priced below comparable listings in the area, with similar characteristics such as guest capacity and amenities, tend to rank higher in search.

So we price a new listing to fill its calendar and bring reviews in fast, not to look good on paper. Expect your first statements to sit below the appraisal. That’s the plan working, not failing. Our fee is a percentage of your payout, so lower launch prices mean a lower fee for us too. We do it because it’s the quickest way we know to build the record.

Launch pricing is a stage, not a setting. Once the reviews are coming in, the rate moves to the market, then moves with it every day: up for the dry season’s big weeks, down for a quiet stretch in the wet. More on that in why a flat nightly rate loses both ways in Darwin.

Shorter early stays, more reviews sooner

A guest who books a fortnight in your first month can leave one review, after checking out. Sell the same nights as three or four shorter stays and three or four guests can review, the first of them before the fortnight is out. So early on, we set the listing up for shorter stays.

The trade is more turnovers: more check-ins, more cleans, more linen and a little more wear. Guests pay the cleaning fee, so the cost of each clean isn’t the worry. Getting it done on time is. Cleaners are the Darwin bottleneck. A missed turnover in the dry season costs a booking and earns a public review, and on a listing with only a few reviews, one bad one weighs heavily. That’s why year one leans hardest on our own cleaning and linen line.

Once the reviews are building, stays can lengthen again.

Launching into the Darwin calendar

Darwin’s busy months are the dry season, May to September. The Mindil Beach Sunset Market opens on the last Thursday in April. Supercars is usually in June, the Darwin Cup Carnival runs through July to Cup Day on the first Monday in August, and the Darwin Festival is usually in August. Demand eases in the wet season, October to April.

When a listing goes live decides which of those months it meets without reviews:

Going live What year one looks like
Late in the wet, around March and April A gentle start. The first reviews come in quieter weeks, and the dry season’s events meet a listing with a record started. If you can choose, this is the window to aim for.
Early in the dry, May and June Demand is there from the start, so reviews can come quickly. The trade: some of the dry season’s best nights go at launch prices.
Later in the dry, July to September The Cup and the Festival still bring busy weeks, but the dry ends in September, so the first reviews arrive as demand eases.
In the build-up or the wet, October to February A slower start, with cyclone season from 1 November. Reviews come more slowly, but the setup gets a real test: the aircon in the build-up, then rain and mould in the wet.

Sometimes the date isn’t yours to choose: a lease ends in November, or a purchase settles in January. A wet-season start is slower, not wasted. The first guests still review, small problems get fixed, and the listing meets its first full dry season with reviews behind it. We’ll weigh the timing with you, including whether it’s worth waiting.

Whatever the date, plan back from it and start early: the body corporate, the insurer, the photographer and deliveries all keep their own timetables.

Clear goals for year one

Measured only against the projection, year one will look short. So before launch we agree goals with you that track the record as it builds:

  • Reviews: the first ones in early, then enough for the star rating to show, with scores that hold.
  • Replies: every enquiry answered quickly, at 11pm as well as 9am. An enquiry left overnight is often a booking that went elsewhere.
  • The calendar: filling at launch prices, then holding up as the rate moves to the market.
  • The end of launch pricing: agreed up front, such as a number of reviews or a date.

The difficult conversations, up front

Each of these is easier to hear before launch than to find out after it.

  1. “Year one will probably land below the appraisal.” Rates, body corporate, insurance and utilities don’t wait for the reviews. Plan so those bills don’t depend on year one matching the projection.
  2. “The weeks you want are the weeks the listing needs.” You can block out dates for yourself. But the Darwin Cup and the Festival are the nights a new listing fills most easily, and Airbnb says the more dates a listing has open, the more likely it suits a guest’s plans. Take your own time in the quieter months if you can, and decide your dates before launch.
  3. “This needs fixing before guests arrive.” The pre-launch check sometimes finds things: an aircon that can’t keep a bedroom cool in the build-up, a tired mattress, a sliding door that sticks in the humidity. Better to hear it from us before launch than from a guest in your first reviews. You set a spending limit, and we call you before spending above it.
  4. “A lease may suit this property better.” A short stay isn’t right for every property, or every owner. If a slow first year would strain your budget, or the property suits one steady tenant, we’ll tell you. Before you decide, weigh a lease against a short stay, run by you or by us.

What changes by year three

Year three isn’t a figure anyone can promise. By then, though, a well-run listing can have what a new one lacks:

  • reviews from more than one dry and more than one wet, so a guest comparing it with the listing next door sees a record, not a gap
  • a place in search earned by that record, not by price alone
  • guests who come back
  • its own booking history, so pricing knows how this property does on Darwin Cup Day and on a wet Tuesday in February
  • fewer surprises: it has seen the build-up, the storms and more than one wet, with our cyclone and wet-season protocol in place

The income is real, but it builds. An appraisal’s projection describes a listing that has already earned its standing, and year one is how yours earns it.

How we can help

Our free earning appraisal is prepared by hand for your property. It shows what established listings near you earn, and it’s just as plain about year one: what to expect while the record builds, and how we’d shorten it. If you’d rather talk first, book a 20-minute walkthrough, by phone or video, to go through what your first twelve months could realistically look like. No inspection, no obligation.

Questions

Common questions

How long does a new listing take to build its reviews?

The first review can appear within two weeks of the first checkout. On Airbnb, guests and hosts have 14 days after checkout to write a review, and the star rating shows once a listing has at least three. A record that holds an established listing's rate takes longer: in our experience, about a year of guests.

Why would you price a new listing below the market?

Without reviews, a new listing can't ask an established listing's rate and get the same bookings. Airbnb also says listings priced below comparable ones in the area tend to rank higher in search. So launch pricing fills the calendar and brings in reviews, and it ends at a point agreed before launch.

When is the best time to launch a short stay in Darwin?

If you can choose, a little before the dry season, around March or April. The first reviews come in quieter weeks, so the busy months from May to September meet a listing with a record started. A May or June launch fills faster but sells some peak nights at launch prices, and a wet-season start is slower, not wasted.

Does a slow first year mean something is wrong?

Not on its own. Until a new listing has reviews and a place in search, it can't hold an established listing's rate. The goals we agree before launch are how you tell: reviews coming in, enquiries answered quickly and a calendar that fills.

Keep reading

Running it

Why a flat nightly rate loses both ways in Darwin

A single nightly rate is too cheap in Darwin's dry-season event weeks and too dear in the quiet of the wet, so it costs you at both ends. Software can keep the rate moving with demand, but a person still has to add what it can't see. The minimum stay, the gaps between bookings and last-minute pricing matter as much as the rate itself.

7-minute read

Seasons

The Darwin short-stay year: the seasons and events that move prices

The dry, May to September, brings Darwin's event weeks and its strongest demand. The wet, October to April, is quieter and harder on a property. Rates, minimum stays, upkeep and guest messages should change with each, and the jobs that carry a property through the wet are best finished before cyclone season starts on 1 November.

6-minute read

Running it

Cleaners and turnovers: planning around the Darwin bottleneck

In Darwin's dry season, most busy short stays need their clean in the same few hours of the day, so good cleaners are hard to book. A proper turnover is a clean, fresh linen, a restock and a check, done to the same written list every time. The guest pays the cleaning fee, and with us it goes straight to the cleaners.

6-minute read